Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.25
Read aloud for homeschool.
This is a fantastic story that opened up some great discussions with the kids. We are fortunate enough to live a comfortable, fairly sheltered life. I can’t imagine a situation where my kids could possibly begin to understand what Francisco and his family are going through, which is why books like these are so important. Reading diverse perspectives brings awareness. Awareness builds understanding. Understanding makes way for empathy. Empathy is everything that this world needs, right now and always.
Bonus points for the author’s beautiful use of poetry to explore character feelings and development. And extra bonus points for the sweet, raw romance that is just right for early teens (IMO - yearning, romantic feelings described and a brief kissing scene). I did leave off a star for the kids’ lack of enthusiasm upon finishing the book. I may have enjoyed it more than they did, and they might have felt more of a connection if they were a couple of years older. They are currently 11 and almost-14.
Really great graphic novel overview of the history of the planet! We also really enjoyed his book on the Dust Bowl last year when we studied American history.
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
5.0
Rowell has perfectly captured that exciting, innocent, confusing, tumultuous mess that is first high school love. But set against the backdrop of Eleanor’s abusive home life, this is not your typical YA romance. I loved it. I would hesitate to recommend this to just anyone, though. It’s not an easy read at all and would probably need to be accompanied by some good long discussions. The MCs are 15-16, and I don’t think I’d go any younger than a mature 16yo IMO. Be forewarned, there’s also quite a lot of swearing and some sexual slurs, bullying at school, and very light sexual content (no “home runs” as Eleanor puts it). I actually felt the sexual content was perfect for the age and handled very well. It’s everything else that stops me from handing this to my almost-14-yo.
LOVED this book so much. Some said the writing was overdone, but I disagree. I think it was lovely. I actually would have liked for the climax to be a little more drawn out. I’m a serial series starter, but this is one that I actually DO want to finish 😂 Too bad book 3 isn’t out until January or February I think.
I hate to give such a low rating to a book before it’s published, but I just can’t bring myself to rate any higher. Too bad, because I remember really loving Rock Paper Scissors!
First of all (and I know this is an ARC), I feel like this still needs some editing. There are a few discrepancies, and some things that just don’t make much sense when the twists are revealed.
Secondly, I had a hard time relating to the MCs. I didn’t really get a sense of their marriage/relationship/chemistry. This was something I noted before the twists and actually made more sense once some of them are revealed, but it made for an unemployable read wherein I found I didn’t care much what happened to them.
I was confused about the size of the island too, enough that it took me out of the story at times. It was mentioned a few times that it’s only 6 miles long and 5 miles wide. But Grady got lost hiking up some mountains he had to drive over the island to get to? This and pretty much the whole premise of the big twist made it really hard to suspend disbelief with this whole book.
Thank you to the publisher for the ARC to review. All opinions are my own.
Sorry, this one just didn’t do it for me. I almost stopped about halfway through, thinking to myself, “What is the point?” Jackson lightly touches on a nice little selection of social issues but without any real focus or depth to any of them. The plot is practically nonexistent. It’s a great example of a “character-driven” story… but with shallow, undeveloped characters exhibiting little to no growth (save for one who “turned around” only after seeing someone else doing it). Reading her author’s note at the end, it sounds as if she meant the book to be a commentary on the damage immense wealth can have and how some young adults are opting out? This topic didn’t even really play a big part until well into the latter part of the story though. I also just had a really hard time empathizing with their plight.
This was an okay quick read. I kind of wish I had just grabbed it from the library rather than purchasing a copy. The spice level is quite high, which normally wouldn’t bother me, but the kinkiness was pretty distracting. Pay close attention to the author’s trigger warnings. Aside from that, the characters were not uniformly well developed. Blackbird was at turns badass independent serial killer woman, and then helplessly inept waiting for Butcher to save her. I actually very much enjoyed Butcher’s character. It wasn’t enough to carry the plot that was kind of all over the place.
I’m a serial series starter, but I probably won’t be continuing this one. Bummer, it sounded so good too!
I loved this almost as much as A Wolf Called Wander! Especially because it’s set around Whidbey Island, a place I loved and called home for four years. I was so engrossed in Vega and Deneb’s story and learned a lot about orcas. It made for a nice book to discuss in our tween book club too! The kids seemed intrigued by the concept of anthropomorphism, and we had some interesting ideas about how Vega’s opinions about humans changed throughout the book. One passage in particular really stood out to me, where she imagines breaking apart a boat and pulling a human child into the water. This is not really a violent book, but that one passage was disturbing enough to stand out and really reflected the pain she was going through during a difficult experience (no spoilers). I can’t wait to see what comes next from Rosanne Parry!