I liked it fine. the pacing felt rough - it would swap between two time periods and the switch almost always felt like it killed any tension the narrative had managed to build, rather than helping to create it. honestly felt like it would be better served by being a movie? I loved the visuals, and there were some good characters, and I really liked the bits from before the ship sank, but the writing and construction of the story needed work to be super effective.
I think this book is going to haunt me for a long time to be honest, and I love that. the different events across various time periods, the interstitial memoir-esque sections, the characters, the boy. everything about this deeply appealed to me and has not left my brain since I finished it. watching the story unfold, slowly and methodically, was both incredibly fun and deeply unsettling. being gay, and gay for men specifically, and trans, made me feel so much more susceptible to the horrors in the pages in a way that I rarely have before. I really loved it
closer to 3.5, or maybe even 4. I did like this, and I thought it did a truly admirable job of setting up The Most Hauntedest House and then having it live up to its reputation within the narrative. my primary problems were that his writing style just didn't work for me in terms of building atmosphere and tension and perhaps more importantly, the exploration of sexual horror themes were extremely flat and underdeveloped compared to other themes.
by far one of the creepiest horror novels I've read. incredibly enjoyable and well-crafted, the characters and plot both were so compelling. it would be difficult to describe in detail without spoilers but suffice to say it is an absolutely incredible Gothic horror