A review by mxhermit
The Avant-Guards, Vol. 1 by Carly Usdin

5.0

Representation: Representation: sapphic relationships (past/present); non-binary character (Jay); transgender character (Nicole); casual racial diversity

Content Warning: Panic attacks

A graphic novel about a basketball team that will endear even those who yell "yay sports", The Avant-Guards is a charming, fun, beautifully illustrated story that will leave you wanting the next volume as soon as you close the back cover!


What I Enjoyed


The dual point of view, from Charlie the new transfer to Olivia the leader of the Avant-guards, played out well. As the strongest personalities in this volume, their points of view set up the framework the brought the reader to the others, who brought a lot of joy and variety to the group.

I thought there was so much energy that played off one another. Tiffany, Ashley, Nicole, and Jay were separate entities that were still something of a family in this story. There were some "rough" edges, such as the romantic history between Olivia and Nicole, but these edges were still good in a way because it made for interesting interactions.

The basketball aspect is easy enough to follow for someone who isn't a huge sports fan (i.e. me lol) and whatsmore it's still enjoyable. The first game between the Avant-guards and their league opponent was fun and sportsmanlike. I actually look forward to seeing more action when generally I'm a "go sports" type person.

The cliffhanger is tricky because I thought it was good in terms of being what it was, but also I didn't enjoy it because now I have to wait until next February for the answer to that email? How am I supposed to do that? *weep for me*


What I Didn't Enjoy


There's not a lot to not enjoy about this! I suppose it was rather short, so there's that? :( I can't wait for the next volume, especially with that ending.









I received a copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for an honest review. Quotes included are from an advanced reader copy and may not reflect the finalized copy.