A review by flying_monkey
Again, Dangerous Visions by Harlan Ellison, James Blish, Richard A. Lupoff, Gregory Benford, Piers Anthony, Dean Koontz, Evelyn Lief, Ray Bradbury, Edward Bryant, Bernard Wolfe, James Tiptree Jr., David Gerrold, Robin Scott, Leonard Tushnet, Richard Hill, M. John Harrison, T.L. Sherred, Gene Wolfe, Andrew Weiner, Ken McCullough, James Sallis, Ben Bova, James B. Hemesath, Ross Rocklynne, Josephine Saxton, Kurt Vonnegut, Lee Hoffman, John Heidenry, A. Parra, Terry Carr, Barry N. Malzberg, David Kerr, Ray Faraday Nelson, Burt K. Filer, Gahan Wilson, Kate Wilhelm, Judith Ann Lawrence, Chad Oliver, H.H. Hollis, Thomas M. Disch, Ursula K. Le Guin, Joanna Russ, Andrew J. Offutt, Joan Bernott

adventurous challenging mysterious medium-paced
  • Strong character development? It's complicated
  • Loveable characters? It's complicated
  • Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

1.5

I probably read this a long time ago, but if so, I forgot how utterly atrocious this collection is. With the exception of Ursula Le Guin's superb novelette, The Word for the World is Forest, and the odd interesting story, this successor to the far superior Dangerous Visions represents everything that was bad about 'boundary-pushing' science fiction of the late 1960s and early 70s. Just as prog-rock provides the obvious rationale for punk and new wave, so this kind of the science fiction provides the explanation (and indeed the necessity) for the emergence of cyberpunk, feminist SF and a whole lot more. The main 'danger' provided by the stories seems to be either self-indulgence or heterosexual white men fantasizing about being able to get away with even more of what heterosexual white men get away with. It's made infinitely worse by the editor's interminable, blokey, inside-jokey, and altogether insufferable introductions to each story - he's great friends with all the authors and admires all their lovely, perky wives, don't you know? - and the introduction to the book itself, which basically expounds upon Harlan Ellison's favourite subject - himself and how brilliant he is - at even greater length. I'm not generally in favour of book burnings, but if all existing copies of this book happened to fall into a pit of fire, the world would lose nothing.