3.5/5

It was so hard to give a rating to this because of how uneven this collection was to me. The first story, "Bunny Call", was a disappointment. I think I wouldn't dislike it as much if it was in the first or second installment of Fazbear Frights but after so many interesting stories we got in this series that kept me on edge throughout, I found "Bunny Call" boring. There was so much dragged build-up but almost no tension. But then there was the second story, "In The Flesh" which I found much more captivating. The setting was interesting while Matt was purposefully unlikable and I appreciate when a story doesn't shy away from building its main character in such a way. The pacing here was much better and the ending was weirdly satisfying. The third story, "The Man in Room 1280", is one of the best of the whole series so far, I would dare say. I was hooked from the very beginning and it was fantastically creepy throughout, with well-paced reveals. It was hard to believe "Bunny Call" and "The Man in Room 1280" are part of the same book with how boring I found the former and how unsettling the latter was. Fortunately, my least favourite part of this installment was the beginning so after finishing reading, I overall have positive feelings about this part of "Fazbear Frights".