Scan barcode
A review by mxhermit
Downward Dog: Very Serious Haiku from a Very Serious Dog by Phinheas Hodges, Samm Hodges, Idil Gozde
2.0
I requested this book because I remember seeing the trailer for the television show and subsequently hearing it had been cancelled. That was a bit sad because as much of a cat person as I am, dogs are amazing. I'd love to see more shows about them in a comedic setting rather than as set dressing for human actors.
When I started reading this, I felt like there were brief glimpses into deeper meaning, but that overall the style of poetry chosen (haiku) was perhaps not the best choice. A format that was even a little bit longer might have made more of an impact. A couple of the pieces I got the underlying emotion, but a majority were so brief and understated that I felt nothing in them.
I wish the book overall had been longer because it took less than five minutes to finish it cover to cover. What did I get out of it in the end? Did I enjoy it? The overwhelming answer is "meh". I didn't find humor, I didn't find engagement, I just...didn't. If the show is based on this book alone, on the authors' humor alone, than I can see why it was cancelled. A lack of substance makes me glad this was a review rather than a purchase.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
When I started reading this, I felt like there were brief glimpses into deeper meaning, but that overall the style of poetry chosen (haiku) was perhaps not the best choice. A format that was even a little bit longer might have made more of an impact. A couple of the pieces I got the underlying emotion, but a majority were so brief and understated that I felt nothing in them.
I wish the book overall had been longer because it took less than five minutes to finish it cover to cover. What did I get out of it in the end? Did I enjoy it? The overwhelming answer is "meh". I didn't find humor, I didn't find engagement, I just...didn't. If the show is based on this book alone, on the authors' humor alone, than I can see why it was cancelled. A lack of substance makes me glad this was a review rather than a purchase.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.