You know a book is good when you full out react to the things taking place and the characters. Throughout the book I was both enamored of Aaron and Rosamunds relationship as it grew to romance espeically considering Ros' personality. With all that was going on that was less than light and friendly their romance gave the story some lightness and was for lack of a better word adorable. My other reactions centered in a great deal of frustration (the good kind) with Rosamund's complete cluelessness and her basically leading the Others to them. Although my other frustrations came in that no one told her so the Chosen were to blame for that one. The end was probably the better ending to any of the books so far in the series as it actually centered on the couple featured in the book. My only problem was that I felt the big climax could have been a bit more but all in all it was still there and actually climatic rather than absent and disappointing all together making that easy to get over.