Returning to the second murder case Jimmy ever solved, Rachel recalls an important moment (and an important face) from her past that she had forgotten about. Set in New York City, the two accompany Jimmy's mom, Vivian Kudo, to a Broadway play that features a bloody finale. Following the main case of the volume is an investigation involving a haunted apartment complex (and an old cold case involving a murdered woman) and a mystery centered around the Junior Detective League. The final case is a team-up between Harley and Conan to uncover a beach island mystery that's been scaring away the tourists.