I was weak for the groveling and second chance type of aspect in this however it was hard for me to move on from what Seth did even if it was a high school mistake he regrets I held a grudge for Cassie lol. There were good parts and I loved the paranormal aspect of this. I liked the audiobook as well I just wish there wasn't what I call a silly reason for him to do what he did to her because that would have been traumatic for any teenager...