Let's just say I am hooked on this book series and the desire to move to Scotland goes more and more each day. Thanks to my aunt for getting me hooked and helping me make my first quilt. While I do prefer the first book, this was pretty good. I did have some issues with Claire and her problem, however the ending made up for all that. I am still surprised that I do love this book because I like reading a series with the same main characters that were introduced in the first book but do not I seem to have any issues with this series that changes main characters in each book. I do plan on finishing all the books in the series.