Scan barcode
duskvstweak's review against another edition
2.0
Credit where credit is due, this series was more my tastes than previous "original X-Men" stuff but it never had any direction. The last volume ends in a parking lot dance party? Yikes.
great_wizzard's review against another edition
4.0
I loved the first issues, while calling bobby’s boyfriend Romeo is a little on the nose it works. I do kind of wish it had more of a lead in to get more invested but that’s the problem of huge crossovers I guess. The Scott stuff should have been in the main title, i wondered when I read it the other day how he knew what Emma did, but again it was really well done. The problem here is, all new x-men help bring me back from a bad case of event fatigue but this second run didn’t have the same magic to it so how is it that it’s the finale that fell so flat, that issue rather than ending the book felt like here’s some story beats they didn’t get to so my problem there is it lacked the emotional impact I felt it needed.
crookedtreehouse's review against another edition
3.0
The beginning of Hopeless's run on the rerererererererererererebooted All New X-Men showed the most promise of any of the post-Secret Wars X-books. Sadly, by the time we get to the end of the run, it's been editorialized into blandness. The idea of young Iceman in gay love, and of Idie going on her first date should be interesting, but Iceman's boyfriend is named Romeo? Uggggggggggggggggggh. He and Iceman are pitted against each other because their families (mutants and Inhumans) are fighting? Baaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaarf.
It's forgettableness makes it the best of the X-books from this era. That's a sad, sad, shame. THis series doesn't so much wrap up as abruptly stop. And, like the other collections of the time, it tacks X-Men Prime #1 to the end to let you know that everything you might have disappointedly gotten used to is about to change again, And not for the better.
I recommend it for people who really enjoy Shakespearean cliches, anti-hero vs anti-hero enthusiasts, and people who just really wanted to watch this era end.
It's forgettableness makes it the best of the X-books from this era. That's a sad, sad, shame. THis series doesn't so much wrap up as abruptly stop. And, like the other collections of the time, it tacks X-Men Prime #1 to the end to let you know that everything you might have disappointedly gotten used to is about to change again, And not for the better.
I recommend it for people who really enjoy Shakespearean cliches, anti-hero vs anti-hero enthusiasts, and people who just really wanted to watch this era end.
geeknb's review against another edition
4.0
The best of the side issues to IvX.
The displaced guys are better than the most of the original. Love Bobby and Romeo. Their issues were my favourite. And so glad Bobby reacted the way he did in the battle.
And I liked Cyclops' issue too. Glad he found things out the way he did.
Annual - doesn't follow on in continuity. Takes place before IvX. Preferred the first story of the two.
Prime - same story as in Extrordinary X-Men.
The displaced guys are better than the most of the original. Love Bobby and Romeo. Their issues were my favourite. And so glad Bobby reacted the way he did in the battle.
And I liked Cyclops' issue too. Glad he found things out the way he did.
Annual - doesn't follow on in continuity. Takes place before IvX. Preferred the first story of the two.
Prime - same story as in Extrordinary X-Men.
mjfmjfmjf's review against another edition
4.0
A bucket of semi-disconnected stories. It's one of the major challenges of the crossover story - it kind of breaks the graphic novels. But in this case all of the stories are good ones, and they don't really depend on the details of the larger story. Sure it feels like I'm missing the big picture, but the little picture is worth it.
josetinocoperez's review against another edition
3.0
Aunque le ponga tres estrellas, por todos los números en general, me alegra que por fin alcanzara el nivel del primer volumen de All-New X-Men (2013-15) en su último número. Cómo se nota que se recuperan aquellos personajes que funcionaron tan bien durante la primera etapa.
Farewell, pequeños X-Men.
Os deseo un buen viaje por esta nueva etapa que va a comenzar.
Farewell, pequeños X-Men.
Os deseo un buen viaje por esta nueva etapa que va a comenzar.
lillian_francis's review
4.0
The best of the side issues to IvX.
The displaced guys are better than the most of the original. Love Bobby and Romeo. Their issues were my favourite. And so glad Bobby reacted the way he did in the battle.
And I liked Cyclops' issue too. Glad he found things out the way he did.
Annual - doesn't follow on in continuity. Takes place before IvX. Preferred the first story of the two.
Prime - same story as in Extrordinary X-Men.
The displaced guys are better than the most of the original. Love Bobby and Romeo. Their issues were my favourite. And so glad Bobby reacted the way he did in the battle.
And I liked Cyclops' issue too. Glad he found things out the way he did.
Annual - doesn't follow on in continuity. Takes place before IvX. Preferred the first story of the two.
Prime - same story as in Extrordinary X-Men.