Reviews

Under the Lilacs by Louisa May Alcott

anjelaconjota's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Me apetecía leer algo de Louisa May Alcott distinto de "Mujercitas", y apareció "Bajo las lilas" por alguna carpeta de libros electrónicos. Aunque admito que en su contra juegan una edición y una traducción un poco reguleras, creo que si esto no hubiera sido un problema, la novela tampoco habría sido santo de mi devoción.
Cuenta la historia de dos niñas hermanas, ambas tremendamente buenas y trabajadoras, que encuentran a un niño vagabundo (que luego será tremendamente bueno y trabajador) que junto con su perro increíblemente amaestrado se ha escapado del maltrato que sufría en un circo.
Para mi gusto los personajes son demasiado buenos, demasiado nobles, demasiado perfectos y toda la escritura destila una intención moralista que, aunque con algún toque interesante para la época, a mí me echa bastante para atrás.

stacynvrooman's review against another edition

Go to review page

hopeful lighthearted slow-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Character

3.75

I don't think this classic has aged well. There are tons of stereotypes and language we no longer use. Story was okay and the writing is good. 

radlibrarian's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

I was a little worried that I would be comparing this to Little Women which is my favorite book of all time. Little Women it certainly was not. However, it is a lovely little story that has its own merits. Very similar to Little Women in that it could also be a collection of short stories (each chapter has a situation, a climax and is more or less resolved very shortly with the main plot loosely tying it all together) rather than a novel, it follows Betty, Bab & Ben on many little adventures. Alcott teaches all kind of lessons throughout in her typical way. Her lessons focus more on the Golden Rule than spouting religion. And I love her writing. You can hear the children giggling while they play together. I cannot wait to read all of her children's stories to my children one day!

"If one wedding were not quite enough for a child's story, we might here hint what no one dreamed of then, that before the year came round again Ben had found a mother, Bab and Betty a father, and Mr. Brown's hat was quite at home behind the kitchen door. But, on the whole, it is best not to say a word about it."

amaliehuggins's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Sweet and true to Alcott, although dull in comparison to Little Women

amberdawne's review against another edition

Go to review page

slow-paced

4.0

b00kdrag0n40's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

A cute, light-hearted read full of quaint settings and lovable characters.

kmcdadepdx's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

This is my least favorite of the main LMA canon. I think that's because it's mainly about little kids -- I can relate better to the books about adolescents and young adults (wait, am I getting too old to say that?).

walte's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

This was an audio book.

The story was about a young boy who had no family.

Of course, it was well written and an enjoyable tale. Through the whole book, I kept thinking about where our American society is today in its practice of our language or more so, I should say, the lack of it. This children's story had words in it that I didn't even know what the words meant. It was so beautifully written; yet, I doubt many people these days would stick with it, and I doubt many children would attempt to read it.

Nevertheless, it was a very nice story.

rica165's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous lighthearted slow-paced

3.0

firvida's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.75

Dulce, ingenuo; un libro de un tiempo ya desaparecido, aunque con un retrato de la infancia reconocible. Supongo que eso hace de May Alcott una autora atemporal💜

* No sé yo cómo será el texto original y qué destrozos habrá hecho esta traducción del franquismo...ojalá una reedición fiable y fiel a la obra.