I read this at the behest of a dear friend. Sorry, friend, but I hated this book. I found it cutesy, preachy and annoying from the first page to the last. I hope the author finds a more suitable career.

This book was trash.

Got about 50 pages in and had to stop, largely due to sentences like, "Every time the wind changed, the gamy, artificial smell of imitation goat washed over the people squatting in the packed waiting room, and the women waved their hands in front of their faces and the children pinched their noses and the men looked out the little windows at the rushing late-afternoon street." The dystopian world isn't so much drawn for us to imagine the sights, sounds, and smells, as it's laid out in very bland detail. The repetitive references to the solvent that's polluted the ocean and turned the citizens of this island refuge to junkies, and the seaboard, seafiber, materials that everything on the island is made of becomes tedious. The premise was a good one, I found, but the execution was lacking. I didn't care what happened to Darcy or her mom. In the portion I read, neither was fleshed out in a way that kept me turning the pages to ascertain their fate.

This was a pretty disappointing read. The protagonist was . . . difficult to like or empathize with. I also didn't really believe in the world the author had created. Set maybe 50-60 years in the future, after climate change created an ice age all over the US, 20,000 people made it to a far off and uninhabited island that they proceeded to completely trash. Somehow, they were still able to have beef and tobacco and cheese [food], and young people understood tons of references to things that are happening now and in the recent past. The protagonist ends up as a heroine though it's completely unclear to me how's she has become one or what she's done that's any different from what anyone else has done. Unsatisfying.

An interesting look at how humanity deals with crisis. This book made me stop and think, would I do whatever it takes to whatever it takes to survive?
A very intriguing and thought provoking book.

The symbolism is so heavy-handed I physically rolled my eyes several times. The book has its moments and the writing is sometimes very pretty, but overall the story and characters are not really convincing.

Omg this book. Dirty, grimy, disgusting, depressing, and overwhelming and dear God I hope there's a sequel.

America Pacifica is Anna North’s first novel. She’s a graduate of The University of Iowa’s ‘Writer’s Workshop’ (2 year residency program that delivers a Master of Fine Arts).

Dystopia with a capital D

America Pacifica is bleak. Now you may well say, “Come on Sean, it is a dystopian novel, it’s not supposed to be sunshine and roses” but to some of you who may have picked up Bacigalupi’s Shipbreaker (which to be fair is YA) and found it to be a nice adventure story with a ‘dystopian light’ background, America Pacifica might come as a bit of a shock.



Here’s what the reader is hit with on page 5:

‘The bathroom hadn’t been cleaned in weeks; old human smells lay thickly one on top of the other, piss and shit and menstrual blood and paper towels so sodden with these things that they became almost human themselves.’

It’s certainly not all dried bodily fluids, but North paints a rather gutsy, visceral image.

The Synopsis

Eighteen-year-old Darcy lives on the island of America Pacifica—one of the last places on earth that is still habitable, after North America has succumbed to a second ice age. Education, food, and basic means of survival are the province of a chosen few, while the majority of the island residents must struggle to stay alive. The rich live in "Manhattanville" mansions made from the last pieces of wood and stone, while the poor cower in the shantytown slums of "Hell City" and "Little Los Angeles," places built out of heaped up trash that is slowly crumbling into the sea. The island is ruled by a mysterious dictator named Tyson, whose regime is plagued by charges of corruption and conspiracy.

But to Darcy, America Pacifica is simply home—the only one she's ever known. In spite of their poverty she lives contentedly with her mother, who works as a pearl diver. It's only when her mother doesn't come home one night that Darcy begins to learn about her past as a former "Mainlander," and her mother's role in the flight from frozen California to America Pacifica. Darcy embarks on a quest to find her mother, navigating the dark underbelly of the island, learning along the way the disturbing truth of Pacifica's early history, the far-reaching influence of its egomaniacal leader, and the possible plot to murder some of the island's first inhabitants—including her mother.

The Writing

The writing tends to be dense and vivid – America Pacifica should really leave you in no doubt of the poverty and deprivation that some on the island survive in.

I couldn’t help but think that while America Pacifica might deliver an experience of the future that will want to make you take a shower- it should be noted that there's not much contained within these pages that is not experienced now by a majority in developing countries and by a growing minority in the west.



A message?

Aliette de Bodard, the French science fiction author recently wrote a critical post regarding the predominance of American tropes in science fiction, she writes:

‘I’m tired of plots that value individualism and egotism above all else; of heroes that always have to be the masters of their own fates, to be active and not take anything that life deals at them lying down (whereas most of the time, we lie down, we accept, we deal with what we have been given)’.

I think De Bodard would appreciate North’s America Pacifica. Darcy is not the archetypal American all conquering hero. She’s a survivor, she has to do things and face obstacles that heroes don’t usually. She’s sexually assaulted twice in the novel, first at the hands of a guard she goes to to report her missing mother to and second by an overbearing, and originally helpful ally. Both these instances and her reaction to them strike me as very real. She survives not by “kicking the guy in the balls” but by detaching herself, by walling off a part of herself- by effectively “accepting” and “dealing with it”. It’s a raw but painfully real depiction of character.

The message, if the novel has one, is a call for humility and acceptance - that the past is gone and we need to change, lest we repeat our mistakes.

The reader is presented with two possible paths; the first a recreated microcosm of old America (our present one). There are huge disparities between rich and poor, a clinging to the past, to fossil fuels, and luxuries. There’s even an ecological disaster gnawing at the edges of the island, as the solvents used to power this society cause the land to decay and slip back into the ocean.

The second path, less explored than hinted at, is that advocated by Daniel an almost mythical teacher who refused to travel to the island. We find out that he began learning to adapt to the cold, to survive in the new ice age. The book ends with Darcy setting off to find the mainland, and people who she thinks have followed Daniels example.

The book works as a critique of consumer society broadly and America specifically.

Not preachy

Despite the picture North has painted for us, I didn’t feel as though the authors voice was intruding on the story. This is due to the focus never really shifting from Darcy. The dictator is overthrown in the end with the help of Darcy’s allies, but its almost a in the background. The importance is placed on Darcy seeking out Daniel and discovering more about her past.

What I liked?

I appreciated the realism, and the shift of focus away from the overthrow of the dictator and society. That there was more fundamentally wrong with America Pacifica than simply one man. That it was, essentially, a society that was unsustainable.

What I didn’t?

There’s nothing that gives me cause for complaint. It’s honest dystopian fiction and that might not sit comfortably with readers who are not willing to examine the implications of what North is hinting at. The realism, might be off putting for those that have lived a sheltered existence. The sexual assaults while certainly not graphic might well be triggering.

Recommendations

Read this book if you like intelligent dystopian fiction. It sits comfortably in that grey area between genre fiction and literature.

This book was a review copy provided by the publisher