A fun take on our 221B Baker Street pals.

V

Sherlock Holmes and Dr Jon Watson as you’ve never seen them before.
Set in modern Harlem, we see the duo rebooted as black men, still solving crimes.
Watson here is a intern at a hospital newly divorced and a father. It’s something we rarely see in other Holmes stories and adds a new sense of depth to the character. Holmes is the master of deduction, but I will say that this is the most empathetic I’ve ever seen him done, which is great because the “rude genius” trope is over played and needs to die. Watching him care for others doesn’t hinder his intelligence or his ability to catch criminals, so this was a nice change of pace.
Out of all the Holmes stories out there, this was probably the most realistic, since they made good use of Harlem by showing its rough crime, but also the good sense of community with the neighbors. Doesn’t hold back any punches either by having one case be about babies in dumpsters.

One thing I really love is how Holmes, Watson, Mycroft, and Mrs. Hudson are all here and while their race has been changed, they’re personalities are affected due to the circumstances of both race and location, but they’re over core character traits are still the same as they’ve been in over 100 years. Watson still has strong morality, Holmes is still clever, Mrs. Hudson is still the kind landlady, and Mycroft is the smartest person in the room. Unfortunately this has only one other book, but this is great if you want to read a different yet familiar Holmes.

This was a really fun modern Sherlock Holmes adaptation. I thought both Holmes and Watson were very in character [unlike certain other adaptations that shall remain nameless] but also fit well into the modern world. This volume shows us how Holmes and Watson first met and solved their first case together. I will definitely be checking out volume 2 and would probably recommend this to people who like Elementary and other adaptations of that vein.

The premise was really cool, the story wasn't bad, and the art was pretty solid; I loved some of the character designs, particularly Detective Straud and Jon Watson. Something in the characters' dialogue, though, just was off-putting. While I'm no expert on AAVE, much of this book seemed to jump at random between classic Sherlockian English and stereotypical Black English words like 'bro and 'kat.' It felt like someone trying to affect a Black accent, and struggling with it.

Again, I am no expert. Heck, I barely have enough linguistics to qualify my minor in, and I grew up in Whitey McWhitesville. The dialogue in this just felt weird to me, thus the lower rating.

Not enough of a mystery or enough of a solution. It was a bit disappointing.

It wasn't bad- definitely worked.

An fun re-imagining of Holmes and Watson in modern times Harlem. This be great as a show!

I had to read this for a class, but I felt like it was a pretty fair adaptation of the original characters. The story featured elements that I'm familiar with (mostly from seeing my family interact with each other and old classmates), but kept the overall idea of Holmes and Watson intact. There were -some- things I didn't particularly care for (mostly word/spelling choice for the colloquial terms) but this kept me entertained for a little while.