Scan barcode
Reviews
Why Nations Fail: The Origins of Power, Prosperity and Poverty by James A. Robinson, Daron Acemoğlu
fclewis's review against another edition
informative
reflective
slow-paced
2.5
It has an interesting theory and model to why poor countries are poor and rich countries rich, yet when confronted with numerous examples that break their model, the authors carry on insisting that these examples are exceptions and not the rule. It overall makes their model useless.
That said the book is an easy read and fun if you are new to economics and political theory.
That said the book is an easy read and fun if you are new to economics and political theory.
slipperychimp's review against another edition
4.0
Really interesting read, I found it especially so living in a less developed nation, able to witness and relate to the ‘extractive’ political and economic institutions discussed.
My main criticism of the book is that it’s simply too long, the same themes and arguments are repeated over and over again. It was also a shame after all the case study examples that very little attention was given to what I found was the most interesting part of the work, being how the theory can be applied to current day events and the economic development of China. It’s very easy to make your case in hindsight - I would have liked some concrete projections to actually prove the theory.
My main criticism of the book is that it’s simply too long, the same themes and arguments are repeated over and over again. It was also a shame after all the case study examples that very little attention was given to what I found was the most interesting part of the work, being how the theory can be applied to current day events and the economic development of China. It’s very easy to make your case in hindsight - I would have liked some concrete projections to actually prove the theory.
thaths's review against another edition
3.0
I buy the thesis that institutions, checks on the powerful, and the opportunity for innovation to happen from anyone are keys to nations to succeed. But I did not buy all the examples (of success and failure) that the authors listed.
nojoneses's review against another edition
5.0
By far one of the best books on the impact of institutions and policy.